The permanent exhibit of the Civil Rights Institute in Birmingham, Alabama, begins with a replica of the iconic Elliott Erwitt photograph of the two water fountains, one marked “white” and the other marked “colored.” Walking passed the fountains—connected to the same pipe but clearly offering a different drinking experience—forces the participant to feel as if he has traveled through time, to a place where segregation and Jim Crow were the norms.
With Barack Obama as the Democratic nominee for the president of the United States, a lot has changed since the photo was taken in 1950. Though clearly a moment of historical significance for African-Americans and Americans in general, Obama’s candidacy is about much more than just race. I talked with nearly all of the young people who were at the museum at the same time as me (all of them African-American), and none of them said that Obama’s being black had much affect on their decision to vote for him (but they all did say they were going to vote for him). Many of the people I talked with recognized how important an moment it was for the African-American community, but said that just that fact would not have been nearly enough to vote for Obama.
Patrick Banks, a 24 year old, was leading a group of young African-Americans and Jews on a trip through the South when I met him in the Institute.
“I like Obama because he is doing the same kind of thing this trip does,” Banks said. “We are teaching these to become agents of change. It’s about looking forward. Jews and blacks have had plenty of adversity in the past, but with enough agents of change, the future can look much brighter. Barack is looking forward where McCain is looking back. That’s why you hear McCain talk so much about his experience, and credential wise he has Barack beat. But, he is stagnant. McCain might have the credentials, but it is not about that.”
Banks also said his choice to vote for Obama was not affected by the candidate’s race. In fact, he said that he initially supported John Edwards.
Near the end of the self-guided tour, I met a young man named Frederick Williams. Williams stood a good 6’3 with a strong build and an even stronger handshake. He wore a diamond stud in his ear and a neatly groomed goatee. Having just returned from Iraq, Williams said his identity as a soldier was more important in the political scene than his identity as a black man.
“It doesn’t matter what your skin color is, it matters what your policy is,” he said about whether or not he considered Obama’s race as a factor in his voting. “It’s easy to look at Barack’s skin color and think that he automatically represents change. He represents change because of the direction he wants to take the country in. I was in Iraq, and if Barack wanted to keep us there, it wouldn’t matter what his skin color was, I wouldn’t vote for him. Keeping us in war, that’s not change. I want someone who is not just going to get us out, but have a plan. If we just leave, it’s going to be chaos out there, and I think and hope that Barack won’t just high tail it out of there without a plan.”
